Symbolic Understanding in Dogs

March 22, 2009 at 4:07 pm 4 comments

The use of symbols in communication has long been considered to be solely the domain of humans, great apes, cetaceans and a few bird species.  Human children typically start to understand basic vocal and gestural symbols at about a year of age.  By the time that most children are 2 to 3 years old, they are also able to understand the concepts of images and replicas.  As reported in Science News, a recent study demonstrated that dogs appear to be capable of a similar level of symbolic understanding.

Border collies quickly realize that their owners want them to fetch a toy from another room when shown a full-size or miniature replica of the desired item and given a command to “bring it here,” say biological psychologist Juliane Kaminski of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, and her colleagues. Even a photograph of a toy works with some dogs as a signal to fetch that toy from an unseen location, the researchers report in an upcoming issue of Developmental Science.

Three dogs already trained to fetch objects succeeded on both replica tasks right away. Two untrained dogs got the hang of replica requests after a bit of practice.

“The most reasonable interpretation of dogs’ success in the replica tasks is that they understood that by showing a replica, a human was trying to communicate something to them,” Kaminski says. Dogs evolved a feel for how people communicate as a result of living in human settlements for thousands of years, she proposes.

Earlier studies have found that chimps, dolphins and other nonhuman animals have great difficulty retrieving objects after being shown replicas of those objects, even after many trials.

Dogs appear to have an innate ability to understand human gestures and body language.  Chimps (like the famous Washoe) and African Grey Parrots (like Alex) have demonstrated the ability to be taught sign or spoken language. Now it appears that Dr. Bonnie Bergin’s idea that dogs can learn to recognize and respond appropriately to written word and symbol cues may have been ahead of its time.  Her “teaching dogs to read” appears to be just a short step away from their now demonstrated ability to grasp the idea of images and replicas.

Coincidentally, I have been working with young Audie for a couple of months on these kins of exercises.  I’ve successfully taught him to search for, find and then bring me an item that matches one I’ve shown him.  We’ve done this with a wide range of objects (shoes, boots, metal bowls, pens, bumpers, spoons, business cards and more).  Sometimes the object I send him to find is in a different room.  Quite often I don’t know where it is (hence the need to have him find it).  Still, he gets it right nearly every time.

The question that arises from this is; are dogs innately capable of these kinds of symbolic learning skills or does the ability only arise from a certain degree of training?  I suspect it’s a combination of both.  SAR work (like explosive and narcotics detection work) takes advantage of a dog’s ability to use scent as a symbol for the object he’s seeking.  In Learning to Smell, Donald Wilson and Richard Stevenson propose that smells “are outcomes of highly synthetic, memory-dependent processing that is further modulated by expectation, context, and internal state”  and they compare the process of learning how to smell to that of learning how to read.

Perhaps the combination of being a neotenized, highly social, scent-reading species that co-evolved with humans and has an innate skill to observe and interpret our behavior makes dogs uniquely well-equipped for certain types of symbolic learning. How much are they able understand?  Well, since they’re poorly equipped to talk or sign back to us we’ll have to wait a while longer to find out.

I’ll try to shoot and upload some video of Audie and I working on the “match game” this week.

Entry filed under: behavior science, dog training, dogs, science. Tags: , , .

A Dollar’s Worth Right Hand Man

4 Comments Add your own

  • 1. YesBiscuit!  |  March 22, 2009 at 5:48 pm

    Audie: A Border Collie walks into a bar and the bartender says, “Hey, it’s BLANK Day!”

  • 2. Audie's Gramma  |  March 22, 2009 at 11:13 pm

    Hmmm … if dogs are so damned good at interpreting our gestures, howcome Audie’s sister STILL looks at my hand when I’m pointing to where her toy landed?

    Anyway, re: SAR. Depends on the dog.

    For Sophia, the scent of a person, and the person herself, are a “symbol” for the toy she is going to get.

    But for every other SAR dog I’ve ever owned, the scent of the person IS the person, and the person IS the goal of the search.

    Narcotics and bomb dogs must all work from the same motivation as Sophia. There’s nothing natural or intrinsically rewarding about what they are searching for.

    SAR dogs — IMO, the best ones never met a stranger, and get all jazzed up at the prospect of finding someone new, The very best ones, after they’ve made an operational find, understand the concept of “human in trouble” and work with the same urgency as their human teammates.

  • 3. SmartDogs  |  March 23, 2009 at 12:57 am

    Because she was exposed to Zip at an impressionable age and caught the stubborn bitch bug?

    RE: SAR dogs. Why do you think non-Sophia SAR dogs process the symbol/idea of the scent differently than detection dogs? Do you think that it’s a hard-wired difference or, as you imply at the end of your comment, a difference in the dog’s understanding of the work itself?

  • 4. Ken Chiacchia  |  March 25, 2009 at 12:24 am

    I think that a lot of we’re discussing is slippery because we’re looking at two selective processes — or rather, a selective process and a deselective one.

    First, as Janine already pointed out, we’re looking at *at least* 15,000 years of symbiosis. Of course dogs have an innate ability to read us — just as so many of us can learn to read dogs, which we would probably do better if we didn’t *think* so much about it. (Think about the “accidents” that wild animal trainers have — is it because their animals are wild, or because there are limits to how well a human can reliably read a wild animal?) So that’s the selective process.

    The deselective process for dogs, of course, is breeding. You select something, you lose something else. Sophie’s line is known for thoughtfulness and relative calm — but the stock is high-energy police GSDs, and that carries a bunch of selections for something more like a detector dog than what Heather calls a “non-Sophie” SAR dog (keep in mind that many SAR dogs are more like Sophie, and that some are like neither).

    Interestingly enough, I think you could argue that humans have a deselective process: culture, which as it turns out has been playing real games with our genes. One effect: it made it possible for people, like our dogs, to specialize to the extent that the suite of “original human behaviors,” which I’d argue includes some dog handling, to be partially lost.

    Not a lot of direct proof for the above, but I think it does hew to what we’ve been learning about human evolution.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Because A Dog’s Mind is a Terrible Thing to Waste


Copyright notice

All original content on this Web site is copyright © on the date of publication by this author. All rights reserved except, of course, that others may quote from original content under the 'Fair Use' provisions of US copyright law.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 284 other followers

Top Dog Blog
Featured in Alltop


Add to Technorati Favorites
Dog Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
blogarama - the blog directory
Blog Directory
Blog Directory & Search engine
March 2009

%d bloggers like this: