“Radio” Chihuahua Explained?

October 18, 2008 at 4:53 pm 6 comments

Frankie the Chihuahua is a hot news item. The Ohio Chihuahua is being reported on as having ears that can “pick up radio signals”. Why? Because people can hear a high pitched noise that sounds a bit like radio static being emitted from his ears.

But here’s the thing. Frankie is a real, live Chihuahua – he’s not an electronic toy. There aren’t any diodes or transistors in his head to collect and modulate radio waves. And I doubt that there are any coils or crystals in there to create a crystal set that could simply amplify the radio waves present in the air around him.

What I believe we have here is a case of a lot of people jumping to an inaccurate conclusion based on a single piece of information: what the noise coming from Frankie’s ears sounds like. From video available here it is apparent that while the noise from Frankie’s sounds somewhat similar to the high-pitched static or interference one sometimes gets from a radio or television set, there appears to be a more atonal quality to it than most interference exhibits.

Folks may think it sounds like radio interference but I suspect that what’s really going on is that Frankie’s ears are acting as Helmholtz resonators.

Hermann von Helmholtz first introduced his resonators in the 1863 classic, On the Sensations of Tone as a Physiological Basis for the Theory of Music.  Helmholtz resonators act as sound filters and amplifiers and each Helmholtz resonator is designed to pick up and magnify a specific frequency. 

The classic example of a Helmholtz resonator is a soda bottle. The air in the neck of the bottle oscillates as a unit of mass and compresses the air inside the bottle, which then acts kindof like a spring, continueing the oscillation and creating sound waves.

Another common example of a Helmholtz resonator is the seashell.  The shell acts as a resonator amplifying sound at specific frequencies, which are controlled by the dimension and the shape of the shell (or ear?).

From Wikipedia:

Helmholtz resonance is the phenomenon of air resonance in a cavity. The name comes from a device created in the 1850s by Hermann von Helmholtz to show the height of the various tones. An example of Helmholtz resonance is the sound created when one blows across the top of an empty bottle.

When air is forced into a cavity, the pressure inside increases. Once the external force that forces the air into the cavity disappears, the higher-pressure air inside will flow out. However, this surge of air flowing out will tend to over-compensate, due to the inertia of the air in the neck, and the cavity will be left at a pressure slightly lower than the outside, causing air to be drawn back in. This process repeats with the magnitude of the pressure changes decreasing each time.

This effect is akin to that of a bungee-jumper bouncing on the end of a bungee rope, or a mass attached to a spring. Air trapped in the chamber acts as a spring. Changes in the dimensions of the chamber adjust the properties of the spring: a larger chamber would make for a weaker spring, and vice-versa.

The air in the port (the neck of the chamber) is the mass. Since it is in motion, it possesses some momentum. A longer port would make for a larger mass, and vice-versa. The diameter of the port is related to the mass of air and the volume of the chamber. A port that is too small in area for the chamber volume will “choke” the flow while one that is too large in area for the chamber volume tends to reduce the momentum of the air in the port.

The length of the neck appears in the denominator because the inertia of the air in the neck is proportional to the length. The volume of the cavity appears in the denominator because the spring constant of the air in the cavity is inversely proportional to its volume. The area of the neck matters for two reasons. Increasing the area of the neck increases the inertia of the air proportionately, but also decreases the velocity at which the air rushes in and out.

An ocarina is essentially a Helmholtz resonator where the area of the neck can be easily varied to produce different tones. While several variations exist, an ocarina is typified by an oval-shaped enclosed space with four to twelve finger holes and a mouth tube projecting out from the body.

So – an ocarina is a Helmholtz resonator; seashells and soda bottles also act as Helmholtz resonators.  Are there any other examples of this fascinating device in nature? Well – in a lovely bit of serendipity, researchers at Goethe-University, Frankfurt have proposed that the bulla, or middle ear cavity, may act as a Helmholtz resonator. And if one looks at the photo of a collection of Helmholtz resonators below:

And compares them to the shape of a dog’s bulla shown in this cross-section of a dog’s ear (the bulla is the large, round cavity with a narrow neck at the top shown at the bottom of the diagram):

You’ll note that there is a remarkably strong resemblance in the appearance of the two structures.

Does being a living Helmholtz resonator make Frankie any less special or less interesting than being a living radio receiver?  I don’t think so.  And — Frankie’s story is just one more reminder that jumping to conclusions all too often leads one into the wrong place.


Entry filed under: amazing, dogs, science. Tags: , .

Weekend Links Aurignacian Dogs?

6 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Susan Hutson  |  October 20, 2008 at 4:17 pm

    While the above is all good and fine, why wouldn’t more Chihuahua’s have this, since their ears are so similar? Also, since so many dogs are being chipped these days it makes more sense that this dog contains a Radio Frequency Identification chip. The RFID chips record and EMIT Radio Frequency. This is more logical, as for the past hundred thousand years we have not heard of other Chihuahua’s having the Helmholtz effect.

  • 2. SmartDogs  |  October 20, 2008 at 4:46 pm

    Interesting point – but the microchips used for pets are passive RFID. They need to receive energy from a scanner in order to transmit. The scanner provides an induction field excitng a coil in the chip when then chargies a capacitor in it. The capacitor then powers the chip’s circuit. And – with so many dogs being fitted with identical chips today (including my own) – I can present the same argument – why don’t they all hum?

    The fact that all bullas are shaped generally the same (and they are not anywhere nearly as much alike as the microchips are), IMO, is not a valid argument that they should all be able to create *audible* sound on their own. If his bulla is a Helmholtz resonator, along with a specific shape and size it would require a source of moving air to function. Perhaps Frankie has a tiny cranial defect that allows his breath to pass by the bulla and create sound?

  • 3. Susan Hutson  |  October 23, 2008 at 9:24 pm

    They only give their identification information with the use of a scanner. They can transmit radio at all times regardless as long as there is sufficient rf in the area they are in.

    Actually the living dog provides energy to the chip, hence if the dog dies the chip will no longer emit radio frequency, or you will not be able to hear the sound which is being emitted from his ear.

    They all can hum given the right circumstances. To the best of my knowledge the reason this dog is emitting is because of the rf in the area he is in, as far as I can tell.

    I could take a meter to read the rf out there, it is only about 20 miles from me. If it is true, then I too could record a sound from my ear.

    Did you see the video of the radio station being emitted from the ear of the human. It only works if you are in a high enough field of rf.

    You may contact me at P3Digital@yahoo.com if you are interested in further research.

  • 4. Susan Hutson  |  October 23, 2008 at 9:30 pm

    BTW, you mentioned why don’t all dogs with chips do this – I answered above

    I wonder why all Chihuahua’s with the same ear design don’t have the sound if your suggestion is correct?

    Let’s research this further – I think it can be fun!

  • […] kind of transistor or chip installed in the dog. Others surmised that this news report must be fake. I think one of the best explanations can be found on the blog called Smartdogs. Check out Frankie the Radar in this video: […]

  • 6. Das Projekt! - The Social Media Workgroup  |  July 10, 2012 at 7:12 pm

    […] Other contemporary uses of the resonator are in dampening or reducing certain frequencies of sound in architecture and vehicles like motorcycles. This is sometimes also called a bass trap. One of the weirdest Helmholtz resonator stories I found is one that claimed the head of a Chihuahua formed a resonator. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Because A Dog’s Mind is a Terrible Thing to Waste


Copyright notice

All original content on this Web site is copyright © on the date of publication by this author. All rights reserved except, of course, that others may quote from original content under the 'Fair Use' provisions of US copyright law.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 283 other followers

Recent Comments

lynellex on House of Horrors
Mary on I Hate Jon Katz Too
Susie on I Hate Jon Katz Too
Susan Jaffe on See no evil. Read no evil. Cit…
Top Dog Blog
Featured in Alltop


Add to Technorati Favorites
Dog Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
blogarama - the blog directory
Blog Directory
Blog Directory & Search engine
October 2008
« Sep   Nov »

%d bloggers like this: