Canine Chivalry

October 11, 2008 at 1:02 am 6 comments

From today’s edition of Discovery News:

It may not be such a dog-eat-dog world after all, at least among our canine friends. A new study has found that young male dogs playing with female pups will often let the females win, even if the males have a physical advantage.

Male dogs sometimes place themselves in potentially disadvantageous positions that could make them more vulnerable to attack, and researchers suspect the opportunity to play may be more important to them than winning.

Such self-handicapping has been documented before in red-necked wallabies, squirrel monkeys, hamadryas baboons and even humans, all of which frequently take on defensive positions when playing with youngsters, in particular.

Chivalry may have largely disappeared from our human world, but it seems our dogs still adhere to a system of virtue and courtly love.  I’ve seen it here.  When Zip was a tiny (less than 10-pound) puppy Zorro liked to let her win at tug of war games.  Zorro was an enormous (120-pound), strong-willed beast.  Before we fixed the problem, he loved to fight with other male dogs.  But he was a complete and utter pushover for little Zippy.  He and Loki (who out-weighed Zorro by 20 pounds) would lie down to entice her to play with them.  They’d let her jump on them, nip at them, and tug on their ears.  They always let her win.

Now it’s Audie’s turn.  Audie’s an intact, teenage goon and he’s twice Zip’s size.  It took him a while to figure it out, but he’s learned that if he lies on his back and stays generally horizontal, Zip will wrestle and play tug with him.  If he gets rough with her or takes the toy away, she ends the play and stomps off in a snit.

There’s a lot of disagreement in the scientific community about the functions of play.  Obvious benefits include skills practice and the development of affiliative bonds.  An interesting question regarding the bond-forming functions of play are the extent to which it is “fair.” Some researchers argue that for play to continue over time, winning and losing roles must be generally equal.  Others argue that both animals will “play to win,” especially during play-fighting.  This new research indicates that, as is the case for most interesting questions, the real answer to the question of how fair play needs to be, is “it depends.”

Dynamic systems theory views social relationships as complex, emergent systems that change over time. Behavior can sometimes be more clearly understood through bidirectional causation, feedback loops and emergent patterns instead of simple reaction chains.  What are emergent patterns?  According to Wikipedia: “Emergent phenomena occur due to the pattern of interactions between the elements of a system over time. Emergent phenomena are often unexpected, nontrivial results of relatively simple interactions of relatively simple components.”  In other words, emergence arises when the whole becomes greater than the sum of its parts. 

Complex behavior tends to have emergent properties.  This is why it is, to a large degree, so unpredictable.  So, while playing to win may be a smart strategy when one is play-fighting with someone who may be a competitor, it can be a bad idea when one is playing with a potential mate or ally.  According to Discovery News young male dogs will let females win in play because:

They might lose the game in the short run, but they could win at love in the future.

“We know that in feral dog populations, female mate choice plays a role in male mating success,” said Ward. “Perhaps males use self-handicapping with females in order to learn more about them and to form close relationships with them — relationships that might later help males to secure future mating opportunities.”

And it’s not just romance that matters.  It appears that many types of social conventions are involved during the role reversals that occur in play.  Role reversals occurred frequently during chasing and tackling games, but very rarely during mounting or muzzle biting.  This may indicate that mounting and muzzle biting are more important indicators of established dominance roles. The use of signals, like play bows, was linked strongly to self-handicapping behavior (i.e. letting the weaker dog win) but not to chase behavior, possibly indicating that chasing is a very basic form of play behavior that needs no formal introduction.

Rowan - a young, dane mix boy - entices Zip to play. He employs a deep play bow because he wants to wrestle.

Entry filed under: behavior science, dogs, science. Tags: , , .

The Onion Book for Dogs Wild Dogs at Play

6 Comments Add your own

  • 1. karlkatzke  |  October 11, 2008 at 2:15 am

    You and Patricia McConnell must watch the same TV shows — she has an article up today too about different aspects of play and the mysteries behind the play drive.

  • 2. SmartDogs  |  October 11, 2008 at 3:39 am

    I don’t watch much TV. She and I must have the same google alerts or read the same journals 😉

  • 3. Jean Rawlings  |  October 11, 2008 at 9:35 pm

    I’m not surprised. In almost every picture I have of Chandler (60 lb) playing with his best friend Crevan (12-14 lb), Chandler is lying down so that Crevan can bite at his ruff. This started when they were pups. Apparently, you don’t always have to be a girl, either. 🙂

  • 4. Dorene  |  October 12, 2008 at 12:35 am

    When we got Pepper, most of the neighborhood dogs were males (unfortunately, many were unaltered). Here I was trying to teach this 5 month old rescue puppy manners and all these male dogs were no help whatsoever — they let her eat their food, steal their treats, take their toys, sleep (or shred, unfortunately) their beds — no matter how outrageously she behaved, they would just look at her with this goofy look on their faces that said “Isn’t she just the CUTIEST thing?” Some of the male dogs who have known her since a puppy still let her walk all over them — spaying doesn’t seem to have changed their hopes! 😉

    Pepper is fairly competitive when she thinks she has a chance, but now that she’s 6 years old, I’m noticing that she’s starting to “lose” sometimes or do role reversals in chasing games with puppies and young dogs, especially if they are Border Collie mixes (few full-blooded BCs in town as they are mostly on the local farms, but lots of BC mixes at the dog park). In the past, she played to win with her peers, but in middle age, she thinks it’s important to help the young build confidence?

  • 5. Satunnaisia leiskahduksia: Koirat ritarillisina  |  October 13, 2008 at 8:09 pm

    […] vast’ikään amerikkalaisen blogimerkinnän koirien ritarillisuudesta. Siinä siteerattiin tutkimuksia ja kirjoittajan omia havaintoja koirien välisistä leikeistä ja […]

  • 6. Audie's Gramma  |  October 13, 2008 at 10:39 pm

    It’s another “huh … duh” paper for me.

    Except I really don’t think the “chivalry” is limited to male dogs indulging bitches.

    Moreover, the construction of social play as a literal zero-sum game as a basic premise, with “chivalry” as an exception to be explained by sexual selection strategies strikes me as reductionist and simple-minded.

    More time simply observing dogs playing with younger, weaker, or smaller dog-friends and packmates would have yielded a more interesting hypothesis to test.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Because A Dog’s Mind is a Terrible Thing to Waste


Copyright notice

All original content on this Web site is copyright © on the date of publication by this author. All rights reserved except, of course, that others may quote from original content under the 'Fair Use' provisions of US copyright law.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 284 other subscribers

RSS New Stuff in our Library

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Top Clicks

  • None
Top Dog Blog
Featured in Alltop


Add to Technorati Favorites
Dog Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
blogarama - the blog directory
Blog Directory
Blog Directory & Search engine
October 2008

%d bloggers like this: